Bad tempered, suffering from a mild hangover, I was eating my breakfast this morning half listening to the Today programme. Not because I wanted to. But because I have a digital radio and my technologically-minded nephew programmed it to turn on automatically at 8 AM to BBC Radio 4. And just to make sure I don’t get addicted to the BBC it also turns off automatically at 9 AM.
One of the Today team was interviewing a depressive. They were talking about some research that had demonstrated that the music of Shostakovich was good for depression. One sentence suddenly got my whole attention. The depressive said: ‘I am talking of depression as an illness rather than just being down.’
Now I am not against Shostakovich being prescribed for manic depressives. It would save the National Health Service an awful lot of money if manics were told to download a chunk of Shostakovich from the internet every day instead of taking an expensive pill. And while I am not a fan of Shostakovich I can vouch for the beneficial effects of my particular fix which is jazz and particularly the music of Miles Davis, Louis Armstrong and the incomparable Ella Fitzgerald.
And I totally agree that what the manic depressive experiences when down is very much worse than what the most people experience when down in the dumps. How could I think otherwise because as I write now I can remember how it felt in my own family home when my father was in one of his ‘black’ moods. It was like a huge black cloud which oppressed the spirits of the whole household. My father sat in his chair totally unable to communicate. Inside, as I realise now, he was suffering even more than we were. He could not be cheered up. Although very occasionally the combined effects of the humour of my sister and myself would penetrate the wall surrounding his inner misery and his face would break into a slight smile, but never a body shaking laugh.
What I do disagree with is the modern fashion for labelling manic depression as an illness or, in the latest psychological jargon, ‘bi-polar disorder’. My own view is that it is neither. It is not easy to find the right word for it. And I don’t want to get mired down in words used by the psychologists and the psychiatrists to classify personality traits. And I don’t want to get side-tracked into debates about the extent to which what we are is dictated by our genes and how much results from the social, economic and political environment into which we are born.
Until I can think of a better word I will stick with characteristics as a word.
Some human beings are born left-handed, some are born gay and some are born manic depressives. The majority are right-handed, heterosexual, and, guess what, we do not have a word for what the majority are. (The point I was going to make was that in all these cases the majority and the minority are not better or worse but simply different. The sudden realisation that we do not have a word for the majority in the third example means that I shall write something different today than I intended when I sat down at the keyboard.)
So I shall have to invent a word. Manic depressives are subject to much wider mood swings from depression to elation than the majority. So the majority must have something like a built-in thermostat that protects them from such mood swings, in the same way that a thermostat turns the boiler off when it becomes too hot. Since I don’t like long words I will call them the therms.
Sometimes I envy the thermos. Their feelings switch off before they reach the extremes of elation or depression, so they can go on with ordinary work and ordinary human relations rather than be swamped by overwhelming feelings. But if I had the chance of another life I would ask to come back as a manic, not a therm. It brings some exceptional benefits. Thomas Wolfe, the American novelist, once strode through the Manhattan streets in the middle of the night shouting ‘I wrote 10,000 words today’. Both the gushing stream of writing and the exultant shouting help to channel the manic energies. He is only one example. The list of manic depressive novelists is huge. (Perhaps one day I should make a list and put it up on the web site.) What is written in manic mood may contain some rubbish but it often stimulates poetry and insights.
The thermostatic analogy is, I think, a useful one in getting a better understanding between therms and manics. The nearest therms get to experiencing what manics feel in the depressive phase is in grief for the loss of a spouse, parent or child. The feelings are so powerful that they blow the thermostat letting in overwhelming feelings of loss.
At the other end of the scale the nearest the therms get to what it is like on a manic high is when they rock with laughter at the Goon Show or Monty Python’s Flying Circus. The Goon’s humour was fuelled by the manic depression of Spike Milligan and Peter Sellers particularly. The best example in the Pythons is John Cleese. The character he plays is the extreme therm, the uptight English gentleman. The humour comes when the character goes totally bananas charging around with a demented smile on his face. We laugh because we recognise that inside every uptight English gentleman there is such a loony tightly controlled by an inner thermostat which is set not very much above freezing point.
In the world of journalism one example of a manic depressive is James Cameron, one of the most admired British journalists who ever lived. Cameron was an excellent eyewitness reporter, reporting the facts, exposing himself to danger by going to the front line, while most of the press corp stayed in the hotel getting the story from the army public relations officiers. But the thing that makes Cameron’s work so outstanding is that he opened himself to the feelings of the people he was reporting on; the suffering of the wounded in war and the suffering of poor and oppressed peoples in peace.
He was the only British journalist allowed by the Americans to witness the test nuclear explosion at Bikini Atoll. Quite why the Americans picked him I do not know but they probably thought that because he was then the star foreign reporter of the Daily Express, not a newspaper renowned for supporting left wing loonies or peaceniks, he was a safe choice.
In fact, the experience radicalised Cameron. He reacted with his heart and on this issue he moved over, from what is usually called in the trade called objectivity, to campaigning journalism. He became a founder member of the Campaign for Nuclear Disarmament, and reported many times on the devastating effects of the test explosion on the people in nearby islands and on the environment.
Thinking about James Cameron reminds me that one of the classic symptoms of the manic depressive is a tendency to exhibit ‘inappropriate sexual behaviour’ when in the manic mood. I had some graphic accounts when I interviewed his second wife, Elisabeth. She told me how he had a wife in every port, which caused her some pain, but nothing like the pain she felt when he left her and set up permanent house with Moni, one of his ‘wives’ in the Indian port. It was several years after that when I interviewed Elisabeth. She still loved him.
But I am not at all sure what inappropriate sexual behaviour is. The social norms, set by the majority therm party, vary hugely between different cultures and they vary hugely over time. In the 1960s pressure from the minority party shifted the thermometer way up to near boiling point. University teachers were jumping into bed with their students all over the land and not just in the Oxford colleges where the elite had always made their own rules.
The therms fought back and today university teachers are told they should not touch a student at all.
Two anecdotes to illustrate the absurdity of this.
This year’s annual Cameron lecture at City University was given by Baroness Helena Kennedy, the human rights lawyer, whom I had never met before. At the party afterwards we had a conversation about Cameron which brought about a meeting of both our hearts and minds. Before she moved away to talk to another person she turned her face towards me and our lips met in a full-blooded kiss.
Back in the 1980’s at the Christmas party I became involved in a heated discussion with a South African student, Neil Lewis. At the climax he was shouting ‘You cannot possibly know what it is like be a black in South Africa.’ And I was shouting ‘So what, you cannot possibly know what it is like to be white working class born in Wolverhampton.’ We got to the point of punching each other and students nearby were trying to separate us. We ignored them. And ended up in a bear hug.
Is the behaviour described ‘inappropriate’ ? Is it ’sexual’? There is much more to say on this subject but I have already far exceeded the word length for a blog I set when I started out this venture.
However the blogging norms have been changed dramatically since I started last week. The President of Iran, acting on direct instructions from God, has made it known that a blog can be 2,200 words long. And I have only written 1,618 words.
I did not post this article, which I wrote yesterday, because I wanted to have another look at it. What I write in manic flow is not rubbish but it may seem like rubbish to the reader because it depends on all the things that are happening in my mind which produce the sudden leaps from one subject to another. Thomas Wolfe would never have been able to get Look Homeward Angel into publishable form without Maxwell Perkins, perhaps the best American publisher’s editor ever. Perkins cut nearly half of the original draft while still maintaining the flow of Wolfe’s writing. I need to sub-edit manic pieces for the same reasons.
Two other issues.
Length. The intention of this diary to articulate what it is like to be a manic depressive. That would mean posts of 5000 words on the manic days and nothing on those days when Black Dog, which was Winston Churchill’s name for his depression, takes over. The only thing I can do on the computer then is play Hearts.
This conflicts with my other intention to publish the blog at regular intervals. After all, you would be pretty annoyed if you turned up at the newsagents to be told that your newspaper had not published today. Clearly, I shall have to find some compromise between these two intentions.
When I read it I felt I had not fully conveyed what it is like in manic flow. At such times I am convinced that far from being an illness manic depression is a precious gift. When I finished the article and broke for lunch several more articles appeared in my head, which would have taken me hours to get on the computer. But they were there in my head.
There was a point yesterday when I suddenly realised that I was typing much more quickly than usual with no mistakes. My fingers were dancing over the keys. Heart, mind and body were working in seamless unison. Bliss it was.
That reminded me of typingbytouch. Bliss is not available to those who try and manage the keyboard with two or three fingers.
Final word count 1,985 words which still undercuts the President.