Cameron Uncovered: political television at its worst
March 8th, 2010Just seen the Cameron Uncovered 8 PM programme on Channel Four in the renowned Dispatches slot. It takes the Daily Novel prize for the worst TV programme on British politics the Daily Novelist can remember. For the following reasons.
1. It was a collection of sound bites extracted by Andrew Rawnsley, an Observer political journalist, and used by him to deliver a powerful message about Cameron. This is based on a notion which used to be fashionable that the attention span of broadcast viewers is about 30 seconds. This notion has been exploded more recently, notably by the BBC in its television and radio news and by Jon Snow on Channel Four News. They give more time in news programmes than Cameron Uncovered gave in its political analysis, for what the interviewees were actually saying.
2.The programme’s credibility was greatly enhanced because the sound bites came from a wide range of prominent people, going back to one of his teachers at Oxford, Vernon Bogandor. They included top civil servants, whose sound bites demonstrated that he would have difficulty in cutting public services without reducing the actual provision for the poor and disadvantaged. And one who told us that all Prime Ministers were at risk from their own Chancellor of the Exchequer, which fuelled the Rawnsley line that a Cameron government was going to suffer from feuds between Cameron and his Chancellor, George Osborne. Other sound bites came from Ed Vaisey, whose suggestion that Mrs Cameron might vote left, was given pre-programme publicity. And, of course, there were the sound bites from the other side, Peter Mandelson, who demonstrated his skill of delivering killer punches, clothed with a velvet glove. There was also Sir Alan Budd, a distinguished economist, projected for a role in the Cameron government, who not only cast doubt on how much public services would have to be cut to reduce the deficit, but also said that Cameron would probably have to RAISE taxes, which will not go down well in the Tory shires.
3. These sound bites were extracted from what were clearly quite long interviews. But what the viewer got was not the arguments of the interviewee, but sound bites presented in a chain of sound bites.
4. The programme was clearly made over a period of a several months. Many of Rawnsley’s own comments were clearly assuming that Cameron was going to form the next government. Even a few weeks ago, that was the prevailing belief. But the latest opinion polls mostly demonstrate that the Cameron lead is dwindling so seriously that, come the day, Brown might even end up forming the next government.
5. While he was making the programme Rawnsley himself adhered to this view. His book, entitled The end of the party’,which has just been published, is based on this belief, which he now doubts.
6. My evidence for this comes from Rawnsley’s own column in The Observer yesterday, in which he admits that this is now a possibility. The last paragraph of his column yesterday, which was not read to viewers of his Channel Four programme, reads as follows:
Most people on both sides of the fence still work on the assumption that David Cameron is going to move into Number 10 on 7 May. But it is no longer completely outlandish to wonder whether the next prime minister might be the tortured, temparamental son of the manse whom everyone, including his own cabinet, had written off. In which case, I can think of an author who would have to adjust the title of his latest book.
Alas, Andrew, it is too late. The book is in the reader’s hands already.
But all credit to you, by reporting faithfully that events have overtaken it. You have learnt your lesson.
I hope the programme makers have also learnt their lesson. Executive Producer of Cameron Uncovered was Anne Lapping, who has a most distinguished record of producing good TV programmes on politics. Let’s hope that she will produce a few during this election. But if she does she will have to do it much more quickly and with equal rigour.
Tough. But’s that’s the challenge of the world we live.
When journalists are asked for their copy, before they have had a chance to think about it.
I am not going to bore you by repeating here the thousands of words written about Michael Foot, who died yesterday aged 96. (Yes, he was born the year before the First World War.) But I do want to celebrate the life of one of most decent human beings I have known. And what better way to start than with the Foot I, and hundreds of my neighbours, knew. Because, like us, he travelled on the 24 bus, which is much the best most sensible way of travelling from my neck of the woods to Camden Town, Oxford Street, Trafalgar Square and the House of Commons.
The other trigger for my dream last night came from a jest in a thank you letter suggesting we take the show on tour. The show was the one I put on at Lauderdale House, the former home of Nell Gwyn on Highgate Hill, which is now a favoured location for parties in the Gospel Oak part of London. This party to celebrate my wife’s 70th birthday took me and my daughters two months to organise. Which is one major reason why Daily Novel blogs have been so thin on the ground in 2010.
kelerle, and Michael, the neighbbourhood lumberjack singer.